High-Profile Stock Analysts Losing Influence
KNOXVILLE – A University of Tennessee finance professor said high-profile Wall Street stock analysts don’t have as much clout now as they did in the past.
University of Tennessee finance professor Phillip Daves said officials with the Merrill Lynch investment firm recently struck a deal with the Attorney General of New York to change the way the company compensates its stock analysts.
Analysts such as Merrill Lynch’s Henry Blodget and Salomon Smith Barney’s Jack Grubman may be familiar to viewers of financial television programs, Daves said, but institutional investors on Wall Street don’t pay much attention to their advice.
“Even back in the early 1990′s, the market as a whole recognized that some high-profile analysts had conflicts of interest,” Daves said, “and would only accept their advice if it was later corroborated by other analysts.”
In the settlement, Merrill Lynch admitted no wrongdoing, but agreed to change the way its analysts are compensated, to avoid the appearance that they are touting stock that their firm is trying to sell.
Before full-disclosure regulations were implemented, Daves said, analysts received information marginally earlier than the rest of the market, filtered it and noisily disseminated it to the public. But Daves said that began to change when the government rewrote the rules for the financial services industry.
“It’s illegal now for firms to release information to analysts that they don’t simultaneously release to the public, so in my opinion the so-called superstar stock analysts serve no financial purpose whatsoever,” Daves said.
Related Stories from Tennessee Today
- Stock Market Turmoil Could Continue (April 19, 2000)
- Local Students Get Chance to Invest in Virtual Stock Market (August 25, 2010)
- UT Study: States Losing Billions To Internet Sales (July 15, 2004)
- Money Handling Tips for College-Bound Students (530) (July 17, 1997)
- Fund strives to encourage faculty, staff influence on diversity (November 3, 2009)
- ECO-STRUCTURE: Solar Decathlon 2011 Profile, Team Tennessee (October 20, 2011)
- Buon Appetito! UT’s Ready for the World CafĂ© Menu Has Italian Influence (March 7, 2011)
- UT MARTIN RECEPTIONS PLANNED FOR DYERSBURG HIGH SCHOOL (January 5, 2000)




